top of page

Should You Keep Your Existing Home as a Rental Property When Moving? Key Factors to Consider

When it comes to moving, one of the most significant decisions homeowners face is whether to sell their current home or keep it as a rental property. This decision can be both financially rewarding and complex. As both a top-producing real estate agent and mortgage agent, I've seen firsthand how this choice can impact your financial future. Here's a breakdown of the key factors you should consider when deciding whether to convert your existing home into a rental property.


1. Financial Viability


  • Rental Income vs. Mortgage Payments: The first step is to calculate whether the rental income you'll generate will cover your mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs. If your rental income exceeds these costs, keeping the property could be a wise financial decision.


  • Cash Flow Analysis: Beyond covering costs, you should analyze whether the property will generate positive cash flow. This extra income can help you build wealth over time and provide a financial cushion for unexpected expenses.


2. Market Conditions


  • Rental Market Demand: Evaluate the demand for rental properties in your area. High demand could mean higher rental rates, making the property more lucrative as a rental. Conversely, if the rental market is saturated, you may struggle to find tenants or have to lower your rental rates.


  • Real Estate Market Trends: Consider the current real estate market. If home prices are high and expected to rise further, selling now could provide significant equity to put towards your new home. However, if the market is more favorable for rentals, holding onto the property might be more advantageous.


3. Long-Term Investment Potential


  • Appreciation Potential: Research the long-term appreciation potential of your current property. If the area is up-and-coming, holding onto the home could lead to substantial capital gains in the future.


  • Property Management Considerations: Being a landlord requires time and effort, whether you manage the property yourself or hire a property management company. Consider whether you're prepared for the responsibilities of maintaining the property, handling tenant issues, and dealing with vacancies.


4. Tax Implications


  • Tax Benefits: Owning a rental property comes with tax benefits, including deductions for mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and depreciation. These can significantly offset your rental income and lower your taxable income.


  • Capital Gains Tax: If you eventually decide to sell the rental property, you may be subject to capital gains tax. However, by holding the property for a longer period and potentially living in it for a few years, you could qualify for a partial exclusion under the IRS's primary residence rules.


5. Financing Your New Home


  • Equity Release: Consider how much equity you have in your current home and whether you need to sell it to fund the down payment on your new home. If you have enough savings or can tap into other assets, keeping the property as a rental might be a viable option.


  • Impact on Mortgage Qualification: Owning multiple properties can affect your ability to qualify for a mortgage on your new home. Lenders will consider your debt-to-income ratio, including the mortgage on your rental property. Be sure to discuss this with your mortgage broker to ensure you can comfortably afford both properties.


6. Personal and Lifestyle Considerations


  • Future Plans: Consider your long-term plans and how owning a rental property fits into them. If you anticipate needing liquidity or want to simplify your finances, selling may be the better option.


  • Emotional Attachment: It's common to have an emotional attachment to your current home, but it's essential to make a decision based on financial logic rather than sentiment.


7. Professional Advice


  • Consultation with Experts: Given the complexity of this decision, it's wise to consult with both a real estate agent and a mortgage broker. They can provide personalized advice based on your financial situation, the local market, and your long-term goals.


Conclusion


Deciding whether to keep your existing home as a rental property when purchasing a new one is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of multiple factors. By evaluating the financial viability, market conditions, investment potential, tax implications, and your personal circumstances, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your long-term financial goals. As both a top-producing real estate agent and mortgage agent, I’m here to help you navigate this process and make the best decision for your future.

25 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page