top of page

Why a Mortgage with the Lowest Rate May Not Be Your Best Option

As a Canadian mortgage broker, I've had countless conversations with clients who initially believe that securing the lowest mortgage rate should be their top priority. While it's understandable to want to minimize your interest costs, focusing solely on the rate can lead to overlooked details that might not serve your financial situation in the long run. Here's why the mortgage offering the lowest rate may not always be the best option for you.

1. Consider the Mortgage Terms and Conditions

Mortgage contracts come with various terms and conditions that can significantly affect your financial flexibility. For instance, a low-rate mortgage might have stringent prepayment restrictions, limiting how much extra you can pay annually without incurring penalties. If you're planning to pay off your mortgage faster, these limitations could hinder your goals, making a slightly higher rate with more flexible terms a better choice.

2. Assess the Penalty for Breaking Your Mortgage

Life is unpredictable. Sometimes, unforeseen circumstances like job relocation, family expansion, or financial changes might necessitate breaking your mortgage early. Many low-rate mortgages come with hefty breakage penalties, especially those with fixed rates. Understanding the penalty calculations and comparing them across different mortgage products is crucial. Sometimes, opting for a mortgage with a slightly higher rate but lower penalties can save you more in the long run.

3. Examine the Amortization Period

The amortization period, or the total time it takes to pay off your mortgage, also plays a role in selecting the right mortgage. While a lower rate might seem appealing, if it comes with a longer amortization period, you could end up paying more interest over the life of the mortgage. Conversely, a mortgage with a higher rate but a shorter amortization period could result in less interest paid overall.

4. Look Beyond Rate: Additional Features and Flexibility

Some mortgages offer features that, while making the rate slightly higher, provide value that can outweigh the cost. For example, the option to skip a payment, port your mortgage to a new property, or convert a variable rate to a fixed rate without penalty can provide significant financial flexibility and peace of mind.

5. Consider Your Long-Term Financial Plan

Your mortgage should fit into your broader financial plan, not dictate it. Sometimes, a slightly higher rate can offer benefits that align more closely with your long-term financial objectives, such as the ability to invest in other areas due to more lenient payment terms or the flexibility to refinance without excessive penalties.

6. Professional Advice is Key

Given the complexity of mortgage products and the uniqueness of each individual's financial situation, consulting with a professional mortgage broker is invaluable. A broker can help you navigate the fine print, compare different mortgage products on a deeper level than just the rate, and recommend the option that best suits your overall financial goals.


While securing a low mortgage rate can save you money on interest payments, it's essential to look at the bigger picture. Consider the terms, conditions, penalties, and features of each mortgage option, and how they align with your personal and financial goals. Remember, the best mortgage is not just about the rate; it's about how well it fits into your life. Consulting with a professional can provide the insights and guidance needed to make the best decision for your situation.

19 views0 comments


bottom of page